Cinnamon Bread Pudding Shake
Imagine a spoonful of warm bread pudding transformed into a creamy, frozen indulgence — that’s the Cinnamon Bread Pudding Shake at Smashburger. It blends the comforting flavors of vanilla custard, cinnamon spice, and caramel sweetness into a thick, hand-spun treat that tastes like dessert and nostalgia in one.
This shake is not your typical vanilla or chocolate. It’s a gourmet twist that captures the essence of homemade comfort in milkshake form. Each sip delivers notes of buttery pudding and cinnamon warmth, making it the perfect sweet ending to a Classic Smash or Double Colorado Smash meal.
Price: $6.59 | 810 Cal
Price Information💵
Item | In-Store Price (USD) | Delivery Range* |
Cinnamon Bread Pudding Shake | $6.59 | $6.99 – $7.49 |
- Delivery prices vary slightly by app.
- Add to any Meal Deal or burger combo for + $4.00.
Background
The Cinnamon Bread Pudding Shake was introduced as a limited-time flavor that quickly became a fan favorite. Inspired by traditional Southern bread pudding desserts, it merges bakery warmth with ice-cream smoothness — a concept born from Smashburger’s chef-driven approach to comfort food.
Because of its popularity, many locations brought it back seasonally, pairing it with holiday menu launches. Its creamy cinnamon profile perfectly complements hearty mains like BBQ Bacon Smash or Smoked Brisket Bacon Smash.
Ingredients & Preparation
Every shake is hand-spun in-store with real ice cream and premium mix-ins — never from pre-blended syrup.
Main Ingredients:
- Real vanilla ice cream – Smashburger’s base for all shakes.
- Cinnamon-spiced bread pudding pieces – soft, baked cubes folded in.
- Caramel drizzle – adds buttery sweetness.
- Whipped cream – optional topping.
- Whole milk – creates creamy texture.
Preparation Process:
- Ice cream and milk are blended until velvety.
- Warm, cinnamon-spiced bread pudding bits are added.
- Caramel is swirled through before topping with whipped cream.
Calories & Nutrition Facts
Nutrient | Amount |
Calories | 810 |
Protein | 15 g |
Total Fat | 35 g |
Saturated Fat | 21 g |
Carbohydrates | 105 g |
Sugars | 86 g |
Fiber | 1 g |
Sodium | 410 mg |
Portion size: 16 oz hand-spun shake.
Allergen & Dietary Information
Allergen | Present |
Milk | ✅ |
Wheat | ✅ |
Soy | ✅ (trace) |
Egg | ✅ |
Sesame | Possible |
Peanuts | ❌ |
Tree Nuts | ❌ |
Fish | ❌ |
Shellfish | ❌ |
Contains dairy, wheat, and egg from the bread pudding.
Taste & Texture Review
Each sip of the Cinnamon Bread Pudding Shake feels like dessert heaven. The creamy vanilla base pairs with rich caramel and subtle cinnamon spice that gently lingers on the palate. The bread pudding chunks add texture — soft, chewy bites that make this shake feel more like a full dessert than a drink.
Unlike overly sweet shakes, this one balances warmth and richness. The cinnamon keeps the sweetness in check, making it indulgent yet comforting. Fans often describe it as “liquid French toast with caramel.”
Chef’s Notes & Craft Insight 👨🍳
Smashburger’s culinary team designed this shake to bring the feeling of a baked dessert into a beverage. They experimented with cinnamon intensity, caramel depth, and bread texture until achieving the ideal ratio — where each sip delivers both creamy smoothness and dessert-like bite.
By using real ice cream and bakery-style pudding rather than syrups, the shake maintains its homemade authenticity. It’s proof of Smashburger’s commitment to flavor craftsmanship across its entire menu.
Flavor Harmony & Pairings
The Cinnamon Bread Pudding Shake pairs beautifully with savory, smoky, and spicy items.
Best Pairings:
- Double Colorado Smash – balances heat with sweetness.
- BBQ Bacon Smash – smoky + caramel combo.
- Smash Tots – salty contrast to creamy shake.
- Crispy Brussels Sprouts – adds texture and freshness.
Recommended Combo (“Sweet & Savory Box”)
- Cinnamon Bread Pudding Shake
- BBQ Bacon Smash
- Smash Tots
Customer Opinions & Ratings ⭐
Guests consistently praise this shake for its unique flavor and satisfying texture:
- Google Reviews (Denver): 4.9 stars — “Warm cinnamon flavor in a cold shake? Genius.”
- Reddit: “Tastes like dessert at Grandma’s but drinkable.”
- TripAdvisor: “Best shake Smashburger ever made.”
- Quora: “The texture of bread pudding chunks is amazing.”
Many customers hope to see it added as a permanent menu item.
Nutritional Perspective
At 810 calories, the Cinnamon Bread Pudding Shake is a treat best enjoyed as dessert rather than a side. Its protein content and real dairy base make it more substantial than most fast-food shakes.
Pairing it with lighter items like Black Bean Smash or Deluxe Chicken Smash can create a satisfying but balanced meal. It’s indulgent, yes, but every sip is worth it.
Smashburger’s Dessert Craft Philosophy
Smashburger doesn’t rely on artificial flavors or pre-mix powders for its shakes. Every hand-spun creation — from Oreo Cookies & Cream Shake to this Cinnamon Bread Pudding Shake — starts with real ingredients, blended to order.
That commitment to craftsmanship and small-batch preparation sets their desserts apart from typical fast-casual options. Each shake feels like a gourmet indulgence made just for you.
Final Thoughts
The Cinnamon Bread Pudding Shake brings all the cozy flavors of home baking into a glass. It’s creamy, spiced, and perfectly balanced — a warm hug disguised as a milkshake.
Whether enjoyed with a Double Deluxe Smash, shared as dessert after dinner, or sipped solo on a cool evening, it’s one of the most comforting creations Smashburger has ever offered. Sweet, spiced, and unforgettable — this shake is pure dessert bliss.
